The decision not to demolish

Gothic building campaigns elsewhere proceeded by demolition: the Romanesque structure came down as the new work went up, stone by stone, in a controlled sequence of replacement. Here, the decision was made to build the Gothic nave alongside the existing Romanesque one, leaving both standing simultaneously for much of the campaign.

The reasons were partly practical. A functioning building needed to remain in use. Demolishing the Romanesque nave meant losing a covered interior at exactly the moment when construction was most disruptive. Building parallel preserved shelter.

But the choice also left permanent marks in the fabric. The round against pointed junction — where the Romanesque arcade stops and the Gothic arcade begins — survives as the clearest single seam in the building. The two systems meet at a straight joint rather than a bonded transition; the Gothic wall was built up against the Romanesque wall, not through it.

A Romanesque round arch stopping against a Gothic pointed one
The junction the decision left behind: round stops, pointed begins, and the wall carries both.Photo: Andy Lee / Pexels

The Gothic nave is taller. Raising the height required either demolishing the Romanesque clerestory or building independently, which is what happened. The new outer walls carry their own arcade, their own triforium and their own clerestory at a height the earlier nave does not match. Looking down the building from the west end, the difference in ridge height is visible as a step in the roofline.

The Gothic work is also narrower in bay rhythm. The Romanesque nave runs on wide, slow bays; the Gothic nave subdivides the same longitudinal space into a faster sequence of pointed arches. The two rhythms do not align, which is why the junction wall required careful negotiation and why a vault that had to be fudged records what happened at the meeting point of two incompatible geometric systems.

  1. Romanesque naveThe earlier campaign; retained in use throughout the Gothic build.
  2. Gothic naveBuilt alongside, not over, its predecessor.
  3. Junction wallA straight joint, not a bonded transition — Gothic built against Romanesque.
  4. Clerestory stepThe Gothic roofline runs higher; the difference reads from the west end.

What the Gothic campaign preserved, by deciding not to demolish, is the Romanesque nave in sufficient completeness to read as a building in its own right. That is an unusual outcome. Preservation here was a consequence of procedure, not of intention.

A stone rib vault seen from below
Fig.The new system overhead: ribs and cells at a height the older nave never attempted.Photo: Mikhail Nilov / Pexels

Preservation here was a consequence of procedure, not of intention.